I paid St James's Place to look after my pension and ISA for years. Then I looked at what I was getting for the money, and left.
The charges and fund figures below are SJP's own, updated November 2026. The opinions are mine.
Quick answers
Is St James's Place any good? Its biggest fund has kept pace with a comparable tracker fund over the last three years. The issue is what you pay on top: about 1.1% a year in advice and product charges. In my view that's too much.
What does St James's Place charge? SJP's own example comes to 1.59% a year in an ISA and 1.67% in a pension. New money also pays an initial advice charge of 3% on the first £250,000.
How much does St James's Place cost on £100,000? On SJP's own example, about £1,590 a year in an ISA or £1,670 in a pension. If it's new money, add £3,000 on day one for initial advice.
How have St James's Place funds performed? Over the three years to 20 November 2026 its biggest fund, Polaris 3, returned 41.6% before SJP's advice and product charges. Vanguard's LifeStrategy 80% Equity, a similar fund built from trackers, returned 39.4%.
Can I leave St James's Place? Yes. Money invested since 26 August 2025 has no exit charge. Older pensions and bonds can still carry one. To see whether paying it beats waiting, use my exit charge calculator.
Want to see what your own adviser is costing you? My free seven-page guide shows what the fees cost from £100,000 to £1 million, over ten and twenty years, and the three questions that tell you whether your adviser is worth it. Get the free guide
My experience as a St James's Place client
In December 2023 I sat down with my SJP wealth statement. My pension and ISA had made about 8.5% over the year. The S&P 500, the 500 biggest companies in America, had made 17.5% over the same period.
So I emailed my adviser and asked, bluntly: "what is the benefit of paying the very high SJP fees to get at best, half the market return?"
I got a reply but it didn't really answer the question. They just said their fees weren't high and that the stock market was risky. They were unable to show any justification for remaining with them, when I was able to invest in the whole market (or sections of it) for a very low 0.07% annual charge, and get better results than they were giving me. So I moved my money and started managing my own investments. I've never looked back.
What does St James's Place charge?
SJP changed its charges on 26 August 2025. These figures are from its own charges page.
There are three ongoing charges. Advice is 0.80% a year. The product charge is 0.27% a year on an ISA or unit trust, and 0.35% on a pension or bond. Then there's the fund charge, which SJP says is between 0.09% and 0.69% for 95% of its funds.
SJP's own example adds those up for its Polaris 3 fund: 1.59% a year in an ISA, 1.67% in a pension.
New money pays an initial advice charge too, unless you agree something different with your adviser: 3% on the first £250,000, 2% on the next £250,000 and 1% above that. Put in £200,000 and £6,000 goes on advice on day one.
One real improvement: there is no exit charge on money invested since that date. Older pensions and bonds can still carry one.
How have St James's Place funds performed?
Better than they did.
Every year SJP publishes a report on whether its funds have given value. In the one for the year to 30 June 2025, its board said eight of its 44 funds had not. In the 2026 report every fund passed, though nine of the 42 it measured were behind their benchmarks.
Take its biggest fund. Polaris 3 held nearly £50 billion at the end of January 2026, and SJP's 2025 report calls it the largest single fund in the country. Over the three years to 20 November 2026 it returned 41.6%, according to SJP's own fund tool.
For comparison I've used Vanguard's LifeStrategy 80% Equity. It holds a similar mix, about 80% shares and 20% bonds, it's built from index trackers, and it sits in the same fund sector. Over the same three years it returned 39.4%, according to Trustnet.
So the fund itself has kept up.
But that 41.6% is before SJP's advice and product charges. SJP's older version of the same fund, with those charges built into the price, returned 37.7%. And the Vanguard fund charges 0.20% a year, plus whatever your platform charges.
The fund isn't the problem. The bill is.
What do the charges cost over ten and twenty years?
Here's what the difference does to £200,000 left alone. I've assumed 7% growth a year before charges, SJP at its own 1.67% pension example, and doing it yourself at 0.25% a year (a tracker fund plus a flat platform fee of about £180).
St James's Place at 1.67% | Doing it yourself at 0.25% | Difference | |
|---|---|---|---|
After 10 years | £336,000 | £384,000 | £48,000 |
After 20 years | £565,000 | £739,000 | £174,000 |
The only thing I've changed is the charge. The 7% is an assumption, not a forecast: at 5% the twenty-year difference is about £121,000, and at 9% it's about £247,000.
What do you get for the money?
You do get something. You get a named adviser who knows your circumstances, regular reviews, and someone to handle the transfers and the paperwork for you.
If your affairs are complicated, or you know you'd sell everything in a crash without someone to talk you out of it, that can be worth paying for. Some people want that, and there's nothing wrong with it.
I've weighed up what advice is really worth in Are financial advisers worth it? The £47,000 claim, examined.
Should you stay with St James's Place or leave?
If you're there for advice you use, stay, and stay knowing the price.
If you're there because someone once told you investing was too complicated to do yourself, in your shoes I'd leave. I did. A tracker-built fund like Vanguard's costs 0.20% a year. SJP's advice and product charges add about 1.1% a year on top of its fund. Ask yourself how much of that advice you use.
After I left, I kept tracking my old SJP funds against my own for six months. It wasn't close, so I stopped checking.
If you want to go, the steps and the exit charges are in St James's Place exit fees: how to leave and what it really costs.
Once the money lands in your new account, you have to decide what to buy with it. That's what my book, Make Yourself Rich, is about. It tells you what I buy with my own money, and takes you through placing the order.
It takes about an hour to read and costs £20. If you don't learn anything useful from it, email me and I'll refund you.
Not ready to move yet? Start with my free guide to what your adviser is really costing you. Get the free guide
Figures: SJP's charges page and fund prices tool, read on 21 November 2026, with fund returns to 20 November 2026. SJP's Assessment of Value reports for 2025 and 2026. SJP Polaris 3 annual report for the year to 31 January 2026. Trustnet for the Vanguard fund's return, and Hargreaves Lansdown (30 October 2026) for its charge. Past performance is not a guide to the future.
I am not a financial adviser. Nothing here is personal financial advice. This is my own experience and opinion, shared for information and education. Whether transferring makes sense depends on your circumstances — especially if your products carry guarantees or valuable protections. Investing involves risk and you can lose money. Please do your own research before acting.

